It's an interesting comparison to my Smith model 36. The SP-101 won't fit in a J-frame holster. It's juuuuuusssssttt too big.
This particular SP-101 is chambered for .357, but other than the cylinder being slightly longer, the barrel is slightly longer too. The j-frame has a true 3-inch barrel, where the Ruger has a 3.1ish inch barrel.
The frame is beefier on the Ruger, too, but that's in keeping with Rugers in general. Find a Smith revolver, and it's Ruger counterpart will be a bit heavier and thicker. The SP-101 is just following that tradition, so it seems.
The trigger is nicer on the Smith, and the lock work is smoother going through a cycle of operation.
So my impressions?
Sturdiness- SP-101 gets the nod. This gun feels like it can take some serious abuse.
Finish and quality- The Model 36, hands down. Smith builds a more refined revolver, it seems.
Caliber- The versatility of being able to shoot .38 OR .357 is awesome. SP-101 all the way.
Customer service- Ruger, hands down has better customer service. I've dealt with both companies, and Ruger is a PLEASURE to work with. Smith got the job done, but we're not communicative and drug their feet.
Feel- the Smith sits better in my hand, and points more naturally. This can be remedied with aftermarket grip selection, however.
Overall, I'd keep my 36 over the SP-101, but barely. And largely that has to do with the lockwork. It's cleaner and better finished. You can feel it when you fire the gun.
But choosing the SP-101 would not put you at a disadvantage, by any means. It's a nice gun, and feels solid and substantial in the hand. AND you can shoot full-house magnum loads in it!
Oh, and I did make him that holster he asked for.
5 comments:
Looks like another fine job.
I have thought for some time that a 3” j frame is probably the Glock 19 of revolvers.
I like the idea of a .357 mag chamber if just for additional emergency ammo options. A .38 special load works much better and is easier to shoot. Given that they don’t have enough barrel to burn the .357 mag powder anyway .38 is probably the way to go.
Those SP101’s are stout and could double as a hand weight.
Ryan: yeah, the 3 inch j-frame is definitely a "do all" revolver. Carries like a j-frame, shoots like a k-frame.
It is a sweet, sweet little carry piece for those times and places where you're not really concerned about ammo capacity.
Put a Hogue Monogrip on the Ruger and it's a whole new gun.
How would a person get in touch with you to have a holster made?
Post a Comment